Join 69,000+ people for my weekly retirement tips, tax strategies, and in-depth case studies

Case Study: 65-Year-Old Couple with $10k/month Optimizes Retirement Income from a $1.3M Portfolio — With Higher Spending in the Early Years

by | Jul 8, 2025 | Uncategorized | 0 comments


Case Study: 65-Year-Old Couple with $10k/month Optimizes Retirement Income from a $1.3M Portfolio — With Higher Spending in the Early Years

Photo by YUNXI SHI on Unsplash

(don’t forget to checkout the video of this case study too)

Ronnie and Melissa are 65 and newly retired.

They’ve done a great job setting themselves up with $10,000/month of guaranteed income from annuities, Social Security, and a pension.

On top of that, they have a $1.3M investment portfolio and a key question:

“How much more income can we safely take from our portfolio?”

They don’t just want income — they want a strategy that allows for more flexibility and freedom, especially in the early years of retirement when travel, hobbies, and lifestyle expenses are often highest.

Here’s how we helped them build a plan that aligned with their lifestyle goals:


🔹 Step 1: Income Foundation Secured

Before touching the portfolio, Ronnie and Melissa had already locked in $10,000/month for life from guaranteed sources:

  • $3,500/month from a small annuity
  • $4,500/month from Social Security
  • $2,000/month from a pension

This gave them financial confidence — and the freedom to invest the rest of their portfolio more aggressively.


🔹 Step 2: Portfolio Income Strategy

With their essential expenses covered by fixed income, Ronnie and Melissa had two options for generating additional lifestyle income from their $1.3M portfolio.

Option 1: The (Outdated) 4% Rule

This rule says you can withdraw 4% of your portfolio in Year 1, increasing for inflation each year after. That’s:

  • $52,000 per year
  • About $4,300/month

But here’s the problem: This approach can be too conservative — especially when guaranteed income already covers your basic needs.

It often results in under-spending during the healthiest, most active years of retirement.


Option 2: Annuity + Growth Portfolio with Guardrails

Instead of the rigid 4% rule, we used a guardrail-based strategy:

  • 6% initial withdrawal rate, giving them $6,500/month
  • Income adjusts annually based on market performance
  • Built-in lower and upper guardrails to keep withdrawals sustainable

How it works:

  • If portfolio dips below $1M → decrease income by 1% (to a 5% withdrawal rate)
  • If portfolio grows beyond $1.5M → increase income by 1% (to a 7% withdrawal rate)

This gives them more income in good years, while scaling back if needed in tough markets.

And because their core expenses are covered by guaranteed income, they can comfortably take more risk with the investment portfolio — improving the chances of hitting that upper guardrail.


🔹Income Comparison

4% Rule: $14,300/month of starting income (which includes fixed income) — no adjustments up or down to account for market volatility

Guardrail Strategy: $16,500/month of starting income (including fixed income) — with lower adjusted income at $15,871/month and higher adjusted income at $20,735/month

This approach not only starts them with more money now, but it also adjusts dynamically over time — making the most of their resources while reducing the risk of underspending in retirement.


🔹 Final Thoughts

With strong fixed income in place, Ronnie and Melissa were able to invest more aggressively, withdraw more confidently, and still protect their long-term plan.

This is what modern retirement income planning looks like:

✅ Flexible
✅ Sustainable
✅ Personalized to your lifestyle and spending goals

If you’re 3–5 years out from retirement (or already retired) and wondering how to safely increase income while protecting your portfolio…

Let’s chat.


Connect With Me & Access All My Resources Here

Enjoy this blog? You’ll probably enjoy this one as well: 3 Reasons to Start Liquidating Your IRA(s) Sooner Than You Think

P.S. Make sure you checkout my new one-page Long-term Care guide.

To your success,

Matt

Explore More from Safe Wealth Planning

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *